VEGETATION-SENSING PROPERTIES OF PALEOECOLOGICAL DATA

Pollen and plant macrofossil data are the primary sources of information about past vegetation composition and pattern at timescales greater than 102 yr.  Pollen and plant macrofossil assemblages from lake and wetland sediments of humid regions are of critical importance in inferring past vegetation and environment, and have been studied from thousands of sites worldwide.  Studies of plant macrofossil assemblages from middens of woodrats (Neotoma spp.) in arid western North America have revolutionized our understanding of floristic, vegetational, and climatic changes of the past 40,000 years.

Accurate inferences from paleoecological data require understanding of the relationships between source vegetation and derivative fossil assemblage.  A long-term effort in the Quaternary Plant Ecology Laboratory at Universiy of Wyoming has been aimed at increasing our understanding of these relationships.  Our studies fall into four broad categories:
 

Theory of pollen analysis: dispersal and calibration models

The conceptual theory underlying Quaternary pollen analysis can be traced back to Lennart von Post's 1916 lecture on pollen in Swedish bog sediments.  However, formal theoretical treatment of pollen-vegetation relationships was largely neglected until the 1960s, when Margaret Davis proposed a model for pollen-vegetation calibration, and Henrik Tauber and M. Kabailiene applied atmospheric diffusion models to pollen dispersal.  Colin Prentice, together with R. Parsons, built on Davis' work to develop the Extended R-Value models (ERV), which take into account the non-linearities imposed by the "Fagerlind effect" in relating percentage variables.  Prentice also built on the work of Tauber and Kabailiene to develop a model relating pollen dispersal, basin size, and pollen-source area.  Shinya Sugita has developed a third ERV model and a landscape-based model for pollen-source area based on Prentice's model.

Our work has been aimed at clarifying and testing the assumptions and parameters of both the ERV models and the pollen-dispersal models.  We have also developed the FAGERLND program, which applies ERV models 1 and 2 to pollen-vegetation data sets.  We are compiling a pollen/vegetation calibration database for distribution; this database will include those developed in our empirical studies as well as some others from the literature.

The following papers present results of our work on theory of pollen analysis.  Our data papers on pollen representation in forest-floor sediments and small lakes also discuss some of these issues and test model predictions and assumptions.

Some other relevant papers: Vegetation-sensing properties of pollen assemblages:  empirical studies

Since 1986 we have been conducting empirical studies of modern pollen assemblages and comparing the pollen data with vegetation composition data from local to landscape and regional scales.  The modern pollen assemblages are from forest-floor moss-polsters and from sediments of small lakes (<2 ha).    Our primary goals have been to determine more precisely the spatial scales at which vegetation patterns are represented in the assemblages, to test predictions and assumptions of pollen-representation and dispersal models, and to better understand the general vegetation-sensing properties of pollen assemblages.  Our results are concentrated in the following papers; additional papers are in preparation.
 

Vegetation-sensing properties of plant-macrofossil assemblages from lakes and wetlands

Plant macrofossil assemblages from sediments of lakes and wetlands are being used throughout the world to infer upland vegetation composition and past species ranges.  The vegetation-sensing properties of plant macrofossil data have received relatively litle attention compared to pollen data.  We have studies modern macrofossil assemblages from 25 small lakes in northern New York and New England, and are comparing the data to forest composition within 10, 20, and 100 m of the lake margins to assess macrofossil dispersal distances and taxon representation.  These analyses are nearing completion.  The following papers discuss aspects of macrofossil representation and application:
 

Vegetation-sensing properties of plant-macrofossil assemblages from woodrat middens

Plant macrofossil assemblages from woodrat (Neotoma) middens are a key source of information on past flora and vegetation of arid and semiarid regions (see Betancourt et al., 1990).  However, the vegetation-sensing properties of midden assemblages have been little studied.  With what confidence can we infer absence of a particular species from the vicinity of a midden if that taxon is absent from the midden macrofossil assemblage?  Is the probability that a particular species is represented in a midden dependent on its population density in the vicinity of the midden?  We are conducting a comparative study of macrofossil assemblages from modern middens with vegetation composition and structure within 100 m of the middens.  The studies are being done in semiarid regions of Wyoming and adjacent Montana as part of the Utah-juniper invasion project.